Sunday, December 2, 2012

Suggestions to Olam in their fight against Muddy Waters

When Muddy Waters (MW) strikes, the immediate aftermath will be a double-digit percentage plunge in high volume in the share price of the stock being shorted. When MW strikes, it always provide lessons and entertainment for investors unless you happen to be vested in the company attacked by MW. MW sends shudders down the spine of CEOs of public-listed companies. Olam CEO Sunny Verghese must be cursing MW now. Why me? When he learnt of MW's first strike, it was fearsome enough to make him cancel his flight while waiting in the departure lounge.

Olam is a component stock of the Straits Times Index. As a Singaporean investor, I do not think this is a healthy development for our local stock market. On the other hand, shortists do play an important role in the stock market by knocking sense into an over-confident Mr Market who overlooks risks. For this, Singaporean investors (except Olam's of course) should thank Muddy Waters for opening our eyes to the risks of investing in Olam and in providing us keen investment lessons. Their Olam report is an interesting exercise in forensic accounting and due diligence.

In this battle between Olam and Muddy Waters, I hope to see Olam emerging as the final victor. Not through the court-room but by business savvy and creation of shareholder value. I would like to give some suggestions to Olam in their fight against Muddy Waters, although I am definitely not qualified to do so.

MW's main thrust of attack is that Olam is a complex business which is not only hard to understand but also easy to manipulate. MW contends that the biological gains and Level 3 derivatives in Olam's accounts allow management the discretion to manipulate profits to mislead investors. To counter this attack, Olam management needs to win investors' trust so that we trust their highly discretionary profit numbers. One way of doing this is substantial insider buying of Olam's stocks. Preferably, the insider buying should consist of multiple insider buying from executive management, starting from the CEO. Each insider should spend a substantial(>20%) portion of his net-worth or 2 years' salary to buy Olam's stocks. A few months' salary worth of buying is not sufficient. Buying too little and appearing too desperate may backfire if investors treat it as a public relations exercise to win confidence. While CEO Sunny Verghese share purchases a few days ago is to be applauded, his impatience to announce it even before the market closed is highly unusual and may be taken by investors as a desperate measure to win back confidence. Once investors are convinced by the insider buying action that top management's interests are aligned with theirs, then they will be less worried that the profits are being deceptively manipulated.

Please, no more company share buybacks. Don't use shareholders' money to prop up the share price, particularly when MW is alleging that senior management has pledged significant numbers of their own shares and could be facing margin calls. Management could be exposing themselves to shareholder lawsuits if they use shareholders' money to support the share price only to see it plunge later due to management's forced selling from margin calls.

Cumulative negative operating cashflow is a major bugbear for Olam investors. Profits are useless if they do not generate cash. In fact, it is worse than useless because it generates suspicion among investors. It was for this reason that I cease becoming an Olam shareholder a few years ago. I first became a shareholder because of the impressive profit growth. Initially, one can accept the argument that for a high-growth company, operating cashflow is negative in the beginning due to enormous upfront capital expenditure. However, investors lose patience if operating cashflow continue to remain negative over a multi-year period and the company keep asking for more money from shareholders and bondholders. This is the case for Olam. Operating cashflow has been cumulatively negative since FY2008. The poor operating cashflow also lends credence to MW's contention that Olam executes terribly in its acquisitions. Although Olam has rebutted MW on this point, no amount of clever persuasion is enough unless you can show me the money (cash, not accounting profits!). Good execution must show up in the numbers eventually. By numbers, I mean hard cash and not profits determined by opinions of accountants or management.

One suggestion to Olam's management is to, at least for the time being, base their staff's bonuses and promotion on cash-flow metrics, not profits. MW compared Olam to Enron for their shared appetite in acquiring companies to create fake profits through complicated accounting. By pegging staff incentives to real cashflow and not opinionated profits, investors need not fear Olam staff are motivated to practise Enron-like behavior of spending real $10 on acquisitions to create fake $5 of accounting profit.

I hope Olam will pause its capital-raising activity for the time being. Show us some cash first before you continue asking for more cash from us. Despite its impressive growth, Olam's Piotroski score is only 1 for FY2011. However, I am not sure if this is accurate as this was computed by a software I wrote early this year when I had plenty of time being unemployed.

MW is a tough opponent. Its latest move to pay for Olam's debt to be rated is cunning. It is an offer that Olam simply cannot accept. Even if the bonds are rated at better-than-expected ratings, it is useless because Olam's bonds are already trading near distressed levels. It is a lose-lose situation if Olam accepts. If Olam rejects, it appears as if Olam has chickened out. This offer by MW was designed to embarrass Olam.

I hope to see Olam emerge as the final victor. Not vested at the moment but enjoying the show. Will consider investing once Olam starts showing us some real money (cold, hard cash).

16 comments:

  1. Hi HYOM,

    I also have been following the development of OLAM vs MW. The story provides me with entertainment and education value.

    I am quite sure that Olam will survive the crisis but shareholders need to be prepared for very painful adjustment period. I can see more capital infusion, shareholders dilution and management shakeup.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Andreas,

      The 133-page Olam research report by Muddy Waters is good learning material for a case study. I read it through and I doubt few hedge funds will do such exhaustive study on a single stock. Impressive.

      Delete
  2. Hi hyom hyom,

    Hear is wishing you a happy and healthy new year! :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi AK71,

      Thanks for your well-wishes. Happy and profitable new year to you too.

      I'm glad I did not miss your good wishes. Lately, I have gotten so much spam that it either caused me to miss out real posts or even delete genuine ones.

      Delete
    2. Hi hyom hyom,

      This is why I have 100% moderation of comments in my blog. Maybe, you want to do this too. :)

      Delete
  3. Hi hyom, I've been following your blog. I'm interested to diversify my money and eventually wanna try investing in Singapore Stock Market. Could you recommend for me a reliable broker? Thanks and wishing you all the best!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Forex Striker,

      I understand that you are a Canadian. You can use Interactive Brokers to invest into Singapore stocks. This option is not open to me as I am a Singapore resident. The commission charged by Interactive Brokers is unbeatable. However, please find out the downside of using IB yourself as I have not used it myself for Singapore stocks. Basically, IB is not suitable for passive investors. IB has higher inactivity fees and customers need to pay for market data information.

      https://www.interactivebrokers.com/en/index.php?f=commission&p=stocks1


      If you want to try out the Singapore brokers which are more expensive, I have written articles on them in the past.

      http://help-your-money.blogspot.sg/2011/06/standard-chartered-online-shares.html


      http://help-your-money.blogspot.sg/2011/05/choosing-broker-for-trading-singapore.html

      Delete
  4. onlinemoneyincomejob.blogspot.com is carries SEO, Backlink, Linkbuilding, blog commenting,SEO tutorial,Backlink tutorial, Linkbuilding tutorial,blog commenting tutorial etc.
    all at the tutorial you will love. The latest SEO, Backlink, Linkbuilding, blog commenting,SEO tutorial,Linkbuilding tutorial,Backlink tutorial,blog commenting tutorial etc.
    SEO,Backlink, Linkbuilding, blog commenting,ETC

    SEO tutorial
    Backlink tutorial
    Linkbuilding tutorial
    blog commenting tutorial

    ReplyDelete
  5. excuse me please, please i need info on how you got started with google ad. am in dire need of some extra cash, and am very conscious of getting it the right way only. please you can inbox me on my email add. at aduayodele001@gmail.com. thanks in anticipation.

    ReplyDelete
  6. cool website buddy I am gona suggest this to all my list of contacts. online poker real money

    ReplyDelete
  7. The blog is simply showing the effective features of the topic I really like that a lot. judi bola online

    ReplyDelete
  8. Continue the good work; keep posting more n more n more. Your Domain Name

    ReplyDelete